Employing Workers

Doing Business measures the regulation of employment, specifically as it affects the hiring and redundancy of workers and the rigidity of working hours. In 2007 improvements were made to align the methodology for the employing workers indicators with the relevant International Labour Organization (ILO) conventions. In Doing Business 2010, additional changes to the methodology of this indicator were made. In addition, a working group including representatives from the ILO (as the international standard setting body) was formed to serve as an important source of advice on revising this indicator and on the establishment of a new worker protection indicator. In this context, the employing workers indicators were removed as a guidepost to the World Bank Country Policy and Institutional Assessment questionnaire (CPIA) and are not to be used as a basis for policy advice. 

Note: In April 2009, the World Bank released the following note on revisions to the Employing Workers Indicator. This was followed up with a guidance note to staff.

The table below shows the main indicators. They include:
  • Difficulty of hiring index: Applicability and maximum duration of fixed-term contracts and minimum wage for trainee or first-time employee.
  • Rigidity of hours index: Scheduling of nonstandard work hours and annual paid leave.
  • Difficulty of firing index: Notification and approval requirements for termination of a redundant worker or a group of redundant workers, obligation to reassign or retrain and priority rules for redundancy and reemployment.
  • Rigidity of employment index: A simple average of the above three indices.
  • Firing cost: Notice requirements, severance payments and penalties due when terminating a redundant worker, expressed in weeks of salary.
Higher values in the table indicate more rigid regulations.

To see the details for a specific economy, use the dropdown box on the right or click on the links below.  Click on column headers to sort data.

Export to Excel | Local partners | Methodology

View Topic Details

Research

The Regulation of Labor (PDF, 270KB), by Botero and others, Quarterly Journal of Economics, June 2004.

Region or EconomyDifficulty of hiring index (0-100)Rigidity of hours index (0-100)Difficulty of redundancy index (0-100)Rigidity of employment index (0-100)Redundancy costs (weeks of salary)
OECD26.530.122.626.426.6
Eastern Europe & Central Asia31.929.925.929.227.8
East Asia & Pacific19.28.619.615.842.4
Latin America & Caribbean34.421.324.126.653.0
Middle East & North Africa21.322.130.024.553.4
Sub-Saharan Africa37.329.339.835.567.6
South Asia27.810.041.326.375.8
Bolivia785310077not possible
Venezuela, R.B.674010069not possible
Denmark020070
Iraq332020240
Marshall Islands00000
Micronesia, Fed. Sts.220070
New Zealand1101070
Palau110040
Puerto Rico22020140
Tonga020070
United States00000
Austria03340242
Australia00004
Singapore00004
Bahrain0030104
Japan11730164
Mauritius03320184
Oman0400134
Brunei Darussalam00004
Georgia020074
Jordan11060244
Kiribati0050174
Romania674030468
Bulgaria17400199
Kazakhstan02030179
Maldives33200189
Mongolia11400179
Samoa1113089
Hong Kong, China000010
Bhutan0020710
Italy3340403811
Armenia3320102113
Iceland442002113
Norway6140304413
Poland1133302513
St. Kitts and Nevis11010713
Switzerland0200713
Uganda000013
Ukraine3320403113
Belgium114001716
Peru4413603917
Timor-Leste3313503217
Yemen, Rep.2220302417
Algeria4440404117
Haiti112001017
Kyrgyz Republic332001817
Latvia5040404317
Lebanon440302517
Netherlands1740704217
Russian Federation3340403817
Tunisia2813804017
Ireland110201018
Tanzania10013505418
Azerbaijan020101022
Belarus013201122
Central African Republic6140505022
Czech Republic33001122
Nicaragua226002722
Uzbekistan3333303222
Fiji110201022
United Kingdom112001022
Belize2200724
Greece4467405024
South Africa5620303524
Namibia020201324
Serbia787203525
Rwanda11010726
Guinea3320202426
Macedonia, FYR1120101426
Bahamas, the00401326
Burundi053302826
Finland4440404126
Gambia, the040402726
Slovak Republic1720302226
Suriname013502126
Sweden3340403826
Canada1100428
Montenegro020201328
Grenada44001529
Costa Rica784003929
Lithuania3360203830
Tajikistan3373404930
Afghanistan020402030
Kosovo00301030
Madagascar8940405630
Congo, Dem. Rep.7247706331
Bosnia and Herzegovina5613303331
Uruguay332001831
Mali3320403131
Mauritania5620403931
France6760305232
Cameroon2820703933
Congo, Rep.7840706333
Burkina Faso3320102134
Hungary06702235
Estonia3360605135
Niger10053506835
Benin3940404036
Chad3920403336
Togo8340405436
Moldova4440404137
Slovenia7853305437
Senegal7253505938
Seychelles4413503639
Cambodia4433303639
Croatia6140505039
Papua New Guinea1100439
Ethiopia3320302840
Gabon1760805243
Panama7860606644
Lesotho222001444
Solomon Islands220201444
Brazil786004646
Kenya220301747
Côte d'Ivoire3347203349
Nigeria0020750
Mexico3320704152
Chile330201852
Luxembourg6760405652
Antigua and Barbuda110201052
Swaziland110201053
St. Vincent and the Grenadines110201054
Thailand33001154
Albania4420102556
India020703056
St. Lucia000056
Spain7840304956
Vanuatu222001456
Djibouti6740304656
Guyana2213201956
Dominica1113201558
Angola6760706658
Colombia112001059
Jamaica1100462
Cyprus330402464
Trinidad and Tobago0020767
Qatar020201369
Eritrea040202069
Germany3353404269
Malaysia00301075
Kuwait000078
Syrian Arab Republic110502080
Saudi Arabia04001380
United Arab Emirates0200784
Liberia2220402784
Malawi440202184
Morocco8940506085
El Salvador334002486
Guinea-Bissau6727705487
Iran, Islamic Rep.1127502987
Vietnam1113402187
Dominican Republic442002188
Botswana00401390
Nepal670704690
Pakistan7820304390
China1133503191
Korea, Rep.4440303891
Taiwan, China7820404691
Israel114001791
Philippines560302991
São Tomé and Principe5067605991
West Bank and Gaza3340203191
Cape Verde3333704693
Turkey4440203595
Argentina442002195
Honduras10020505795
Portugal3347504397
Paraguay5653605699
Comoros39404040100
Guatemala4440028101
Bangladesh4404028104
Indonesia6106040108
Sudan39205036118
Egypt, Arab Rep.0206027132
Equatorial Guinea67607066133
Mozambique67332040134
Ecuador44403038135
Lao PDR1105020162
Ghana11205027178
Zambia11332021178
Sierra Leone33405041189
Sri Lanka006020217
Zimbabwe0406033446